Pre-budget scrutiny 2027–28: Public service reform

The RSE welcomes the opportunity to contribute to the Committee’s consultation. This response draws on insights from a dedicated working group of RSE Fellows with expertise in public and third sector policy and delivery. In addition, it draws on previous RSE recommendations on public sector reform (PSR), in particular the joint report with Audit Scotland, Public service reform in Scotland: how do we turn rhetoric into reality?

Download the advice paper, Pre-budget scrutiny 2027–28: Public service reform (340KB, PDF)

Executive summary

The RSE contribution highlights the need to complement high-level, abstract principles such as those set out in the Public Service Reform Strategy with an action plan with specific, concrete propositions for material changes and improvements across identified public sector services or policies.

If public services are to be fiscally sustainable in the long run, a programme of reforms is needed with major and transformational changes across different services that can be expected to deliver more output and better outcomes at lower cost.

Such a programme of transformational reforms will ensure the ambitions to transform public service delivery and to achieve designated savings are met. Moreover, that preventative action becomes central, rather than aspirational, as outlined in the recommendations of the Christie Commission.

General points

Although not by any means new, public service reform has become a key challenge to ensure the sustainability of our public sector in the long run, and the RSE commends the current Government for prioritising this area of activity. Creating a dedicated senior position at Cabinet Secretary level to oversee the delivery of this reform drives this message through. In addition to the specific responses for each of the consultation questions presented above, we take this opportunity to include below a series of high-level remarks that are pertinent across the questions raised, and the public service reform more generally, that the Committee might like to consider.

Too much discussion on “reform” is abstract and high-level. While the Scottish Government’s Public Service Reform Strategy sets out generally welcome principles, it contains few actual plans for reform. General statements on what is desirable are not matched by an action plan with specific, concrete propositions for material changes and improvements across identified public sector services or policies.

If public services are to be fiscally sustainable in the long run, a programme of reforms is needed: major and transformational changes across different services that can be expected to deliver more output and better outcomes at lower cost. Each must be underlain by a long-term vision and strategy – that is informed by the views of those involved in running, managing, delivering, and benefiting from the public services, who are often well-placed to devise innovation solutions drawing on their direct experience of the system. Government should continue to support and encourage this and reset the balance between top-down and bottom-up approaches.

Overly centralising decision-making18 can be problematic and the RSE reiterates the need for a better-balanced system. National system design (e.g. to enable necessary legislative change) and national stewardship and oversight are needed to support coherence across public services. However, for the reasons outlined above, local actors (local authorities, public bodies, and the emerging regional structures) must be genuinely empowered to develop place-based policy initiatives, recognising that enduring fiscal pressures can make this increased autonomy more challenging to deliver. The RSE therefore strongly welcomes the commitment in the Public Service Reform Strategy to devolve markedly more responsibilities to the regional level, and encourages the Scottish Government to progress this early and energetically.

Cash releasing efficiencies of 0.5 billion per annum may sound readily achievable, but cannot be applied to cash entitlements, or spending programmes that Ministers choose to exempt. If applied to the remainder of the budget, the resultant savings will almost certainly fall short of the total efficiencies being sought.

About half of the Scottish budget covers the direct cost of public employees. In Scotland, 22% of the workforce is in the public sector, compared to 17% at UK level; furthermore, Scottish public sector pay levels have also risen comparatively higher in recent years. It is inevitable, therefore, that the Public Service Reform Strategy focuses on workforce reduction. We suggest reforms to pay structures should also be considered. The Public Service Reform Strategy’s expectation of a 0.5% per annum reduction in workforce numbers is only about one tenth of the annual turnover often seen through natural attrition. However, if some services are exempted from reductions, or major reforms happen in individual services, the government’s policy of compulsory redundancies only as a last resort may well be tested.

Change is risky, but seeking to minimise all risks can delay progress. As noted by the RSE and Audit Scotland, the current culture is such that we often see a reduced tolerance for risk among public sector leaders. Government must be more prepared to accept calculated risk whilst still exercising appropriate caution.

Better-managed data can make significant public service improvements possible: data-rich environments lead to better decisions. The RSE has repeatedly called for improved large-scale data gathering and transmission. Data sharing can avoid duplicated data collection, but the current fragmented system often prevents effective sharing of positive preventative practices and, by extension, improved delivery of person-centred services.

Current data surrounding person-centred services also suggest that, rather than aiming for universal provision or entitlements, constrained budgets may be better spent on targeted intervention for those who need specific services or support most. There can admittedly be trade-offs associated with the administrative costs of targeting, but moving away from homogenous universal provision to a focussed approach may be an as-yet largely untapped opportunity for major reforms.

The Public Service Reform Strategy focuses mainly on managing resources. However, public sector investments are crucial to achieve the increases in productivity that are critical for our economy and public finances. In a constrained budget, getting better value from capital expenditure is vital. Past performance suggests that more disciplined procurement is needed to deliver on time and within budget. The Scottish Government should also reflect on the regulatory constraints (some of which are devolved, e.g. planning) which make capital projects in Britain much more expensive and slower than in other countries.

The RSE also recommends learning from international best practice in public service reform, with examples such as the Netherlands providing progressive approaches to integrating health and social care.

Download

Download the advice paper, Pre-budget scrutiny 2027–28: Public service reform (340KB, PDF)

You might also like